Search:

Last 3 Posts @ May 17, 2008 1:04:25 PM EDT

NOT BRASSED OFF..... (17 hrs, 59 mins ago)

Apologies for not blogging earlier on but today recovering from Mayor-making last night in Mytholmroyd. Thanks to Hebden Bridge Junior Band for saving the day and pra...

Grimmer Up North

Transparency = popularity. Apparently (18 hrs, 23 mins ago)

The good ol’ High Court seems to have had the final word on whether the details of MPs’ expenses claims are published. Well, transparency is what it’...

And another thing...

Rangers riot aftermath (18 hrs, 25 mins ago)

<!--Mime Type of File is image/jpeg --> Manchester United fans are to pay the price for the Glasgow Rangers riot, which took place here in Piccadilly Gardens not tw...

Stephen Newton's diary of sorts...

Friday, May 11, 2007

The Commentariat, again - 2 comments

This is good, from the Ministry of Truth:
For all the professional commentariat complain bitterly of their rather 'robust' and ungentle handling by some bloggers and a few anonymous blog-trolls, it should be noted that there is nothing that pisses them off quite so much as those occasions on which their standard charge of amateurism contrives to explode in their face.

This latest spate of sniping from the hallowed ranks of the professional commentariat has, I will freely admit. prompted me to contemplate a pivotal question.

Just what, exactly, is it that journalists - or rather columnists, as there is little by way of real friction between most bloggers and other subspecies of the genus 'Journalista' - possess that bloggers do not, such that these columnists routinely operate from a presumption of their own professional and intellectual superiority?

The only answer that seems to fit, having pondered the subject, is that with payment for one’s opinions comes the hubristic belief that one’s ability to string together words in a more or less grammatically correct and pleasing manner automatically confers on oneself the status of being an ecumenical authority on any and all subjects to which one turns ones attention.
My last take on this topic.

Labels: , ,

2 comments so far...

At 3:04 AM, May 11, 2007, Blogger SC said...

Hmmm. It's good, but a bit verbose.

;)

(I think the real answer is that they quite understandably feel under threat...)

   
At 12:15 AM, May 12, 2007, Blogger Finnieston Crane said...

I'm inclined to agree broadly. I've heard it said in the past that the best commentators stick to one area of interest, i.e., Polly Toynbee and social justice. However, I don't think it holds true. George Monbiot is ostensibly a 'Green' campaigner but writes on all sorts. Oddly, I've always wanted to be a journalist but recognise that people such as those mentioned simply take a stance and run with it. They are utterly unaccountable. Which makes me wonder if people like Richard Littlejohn truly believe what they write or whether they do it just to remain in a job.

   

Post a Comment

<< Home

B4L Running Costs

£1,746.30 spent so far this year, which could be met by a donation of £3.45 per blogger.




Join the Labour Party
Sign the Euston Manifesto


Wikispaces