They Will Come For You - 5 comments
Via Pub Philosopher, a distinctly unsavoury attempt by 'our own' Diane Abbott MP (her name is misspelled in their article, though more on this later) to spread the fear of racism - and fear and mistrust of the police - among black Britons.
Familiar themes are covered; you've seen it all before, but here we go just once more time:
For one thing, the billions that Blair is spending on his wars in Afghanistan and Iraq could have been better spent on schools and hospitals here at home.Frankly, I'm disgusted at that - at the very least, it's unworthy of an MP.
How can it be that Blair has a billion pounds to spend on sending troops to Afghanistan, chasing around looking for Osama Bin Laden (who is probably in a hotel room in New York watching it all on CNN), when there is no money to provide decent facilities for the youth in Hackney?
Now, how does Diane make the jump from media condemnation (much of it justified, leaving aside the tabloid accounts) of violence-inciting Islamic protests to conjure up the spectre of orchestrated racism against black people? Simply and shamelessly:
What this media coverage plays on is fear of the outsider and the "foreigner" and, above all, the oldest racial stereotype in the book: the idea that non-white men are violent.In other words, from one of her own hang-ups - no more, no less.
And I have no doubt that some of the "anti-terrorist" legislation that Tony Blair is trying to push through parliament, including 90-day detention without trial and arbitrary house arrest, will end up being used on black and Asian people generally.I don't doubt that Muslims are disproportionally suspected of being involved in terrorism (and I mean disproportionately to the actual involvement of Muslims in terrorism, not disproportionately to other groups in society), but I certainly don't believe that any group is suspected generally, seemingly on the whim of the authorities, as Diane would have us believe. No reason whatsoever is given as to why black people might be victimised - and not defended by the rest of society - let alone people hailing from India, Uzbekistan, Vietnam, or Japan, whom Diane also seems to believe she has a right to speak for.
So beware of Tony Blair and his "war on terror". If they come for the young Muslim man next door in the morning; they will come for you in the afternoon.
I guess it's possible that The Voice are doing the old Viz trick: "Diane Abbot is an unemployed agitator from West Norwood and in no way connected to Diane Abbott, the MP of unimpeachable integrity and moral character". It's mysterious, though: there seem to be plenty of Google hits for both variations of the name, seemingly both referring to the same person, so I'll continue to work on the basis that this nastiness was perpatrated by one of our own MPs, hard as it is to believe.










![Validate my Atom feed [Valid Atom]](http://www.bloggers4labour.org/images/valid-atom.png)






5 comments so far...
To "spread the fear of racism" amongst Black-britons? I rather suspect that that is a horse which has bolted the stable.
That elements of the media repeatedly perpetuate the line that the "other" represents our deepest fears is surely beyond dispute. That the british police force have a long history of racism tarnishing their record is equally self-evident.
It is simply a matter of fact that young british blacks and asians are targeted by police. I can't believe that you'd dispute that. Even the most benevolent view of the police has to acknowledge that statistics - for a variety of reasons - support that.
The relentless demonisation of muslims in the media is hardly likely to help this, is it? The more talk of this utterly absurd 'clash of civilisations' the more cemented the notion becomes that there is some chasm between 'us' and 'them'. And there remains no clear definition of 'them'; my suspicion is that Abbott is dead right, that it is people of all ethnic minorities that will suffer.
Whether Abbott is guilty of whipping up unease or not - I'm minded to think that she's well equipped and entitled to comment on a serious matter - nothing she actually says is untrue.
It used to be the case that everyone on the left could be relied upon to support the fight against racism. If Abbott sounds old fashioned now, it is simply because she's the only one who is still shouting.
The central point of her argument was that, as a result of the war on terror (ooh, I didn't even use scare quotes!), not only would both black and Asian people - yes, people from every part of a continent with, what, 3 billion people, as well as people with a melanin concentration above a certain threshold - face more racism than before (and nobody's denying this occurs, nor did I deny that certain groups are disproportionately suspected of involvement in terrorism), but this would, in a sense, be orchestrated, with the PM complicit, and the rest of the population apparently uncaring. That's an outrageous claim, and I can't see any reason to make it other than to push a few political buttons and big herself up in the eyes of those groups she thinks might go for this kind of rant.
Of course there might conceivably be greater racism against "blacks and Asians" but if she thinks she can blame a particular issue for it, and pin that on Blair, her own government, and/or those who support the war on terror, and in so doing fuel the idea that the police are so irretrievably racist that they can never be trusted on any issue, then I believe that's an utterly cynical, and damaging, position to take. It can only do harm to the anti-racist movement as a whole.
I take your point, but I don't think she was arguing that Blair was complicit in any drive to victimise ethnic minorities, at least not deliberately.
But it's a fair point to make that the "war" on terror which Blair made a considerable effort to support does seem to have - through a frighteningly bad bit of judgement on the behalf of the govt - raised the stakes considerably in terms of global terrorism.
That's the case, and in trying to stop future acts it's unfortunately the case that ethnic minorities will continue to be stigmatised and stereotyped.
It is certainly the case that supporters of the war on terror did not intend that to be the case - nevertheless they played a significant part in making it so, and Abbott is entitled to point that out.
If you acknowledge that there may be more racism against ethnic minorities, what other explanation do you have apart from that posited by Abbott? Of course the press play their part in stoking the flames, but the government has for the most part failed to contradict them. It's no good accusing the Daily Express of being a liar when everyone knows that you've told serial lies yourself.
Britain forward not back
Bad Abbot.
Backwards Abbott.
That's the spirit!
Post a Comment
<< Home